The term summarizes a paradox that those naturally gifted resource countries do not always develop and grow their economies. While most published studies report evidence that is consistent with the idea of a resource curse, there is considerable disagreement about the mechanisms that cause the 42 Pages Posted: 11 Jul 2016 Last revised: 2 Oct 2018. The "subnational resource curse" refers to the overall negative effects of natural resource wealth in the economy, politics, polity or environment of a subnational area. As a result, many see a 'resource curse' in Africa, whereby easily obtainable natural resources and commodities have essentially hurt the prospects of several African national and regional economies by fostering political corruption and feeding Resource curse theory examines the negative effects of rich natural resources on economic growth from an economic and political perspective. Keywords: resource curse, economic perform ance, rentier state, rent-seeking models, resource . Natural gas, copper, and diamonds are also bad for a country's health. By definition, resource curse, also called the paradox of plenty, refers to a situation where countries endowed with a natural resource curse tend to record slow economic growth as compared to countries with fewer natural resources. According to one count, the academic literature has grown from thirteen academic papers covering some aspect of the resource curse in 1995 to 543 in 2005 and 2420 in 2014 (Gilberthorpe and Papyrakis, 2015). Using the Natural Resource Charter as a framework, the course covers: 1) Designing and Evaluating Fiscal Regimes, 2) Distributing, Managing and Spending Resource Revenues, and 3) The Political Economy of Policymaking in Resource-Rich States. 'Industrial policy reform in six large newly industrialising countries' (Vol 22, No.1, pp. Figure 1 shows GDP per capita at purchasing power parity for highly resource-intensive countries such as Saudi Arabia, Nigeria, Venezuela and Zaire, and for . Resource Curse Theory Pdf Creator. Instead of benefiting and prospering the country and its citizen, the . In development economics, there are few topics that capture academia's imagination as intensively as the resource curse. "'The Resource Curse': Why Africa's Oil Riches Don't Trickle Down to Africans." Knowledge@Wharton. The Resource Curse The existence of a resource curse is highly debated in the literature. A place of conflict, brutality, and exploitation, the Congo documented by Marlow, a Belgian traveler journeying up the Congo River in search . 130/ Dutch Disease, Rentier State, and Resource Curse: … of those resources are much prosperous and whether than countries that are deprived of the very resources. We show that when political institutions are cohesive and power is shared among the diverse groups in a multi-ethnic society, Second, the risk of resource curse symptoms varies by commodity: it is higher the larger and more volatile the commodity revenue, and the greater its . The term as used here refers to the phenomenon whereby countries with an abundance of natural resources grow more slowly than those without such an abundance. Introduction. developed to developing countries. Despite many advances in this literature, a core concept—resource rents—remains under-theorized, and even less well measured. More natural resources push aggregate income down, when institutions are grabber friendly, while more resources raise income, when institutions are producer friendly. 1. The subsequent two decades saw the emergence of a significant body of research proposing a link between resource production, economic underperformance and various socio-political ills. This is the phenomenon known as the Natural Resource Curse. Resource curse • Oil is a curse. While it most often refers to natural resource discovery, it can also refer to . Summary: This paper undertakes a critical survey of the 'resource curse' -the idea that The present survey casts a wider net, is intended for a more general audience, and offers policy prescriptions. Figure 1. icant shortcomings in terms of theory and evidence. O1,Q0 ABSTRACT It is striking how often countries with oil or other natural resource wealth have failed to grow more rapidly than those without. The 'Resource Curse': Theory and Evidence (ARI) Jonathan Di John* Theme: Mineral and fuel abundance does not determine either the political or economic trajectory of less developed countries. The above is first confirmed by Sachs and Warner in many of their research on the same subject (1995, 1997a, b, c, 1999a, b, 2001), and later it became a . The term as used here refers to the phenomenon whereby countries with an abundance of natural resources grow more slowly than those without such an abundance. A large body of scholarship finds a negative relationship between natural resources and democracy. Table1 Regressionofeconomicgrowthonnaturalresourceabundance,1970}1990,controllingforgrowth inthe1960s LogGDP1970 !1.8 (8.87) Naturalresourceabundance !9.9 • Poor but resource-rich countries tend to be underdeveloped not despite their hydrocarbon and mineral riches but because of their resource wealth. The resource curse, also known as the paradox of plenty or the poverty paradox, is the phenomenon of countries with an abundance of natural resources (such as fossil fuels and certain minerals) having less economic growth, less democracy, or worse development outcomes than countries with fewer natural resources. • Poor but resource-rich countries tend to be underdeveloped not despite their hydrocarbon and mineral riches but because of their resource wealth. Firstly, despite touting the mining sector as significant in the economic revival of the country and the drive to . The Myth of the Resource Curse: A Case Study of Algeria Mohammed Akacem Metropolitan State University of Denver The Journal of Private Enterprise 32 (2), 2017, 1 - 15 Nicolás Cachanosky Metropolitan State University of Denver _____ Abstract This paper compares Algeria to Norway in the context of the resource curse theory. From this perspective a country must diversify its economy in order to develop. The Resource Curse refers to the phenomenon of worse economic performance in resource-abundant countries comparing to resource-poor countries (Auty, 1993, p.1). The financial support of the Nuffield Foundation, British Academy, RTZ and World Bank is gratefully acknowledged. Resource curse. The resource curse is a complicated phenomenon that results from a variety of reasons, including the Dutch disease, rent seeking, crowding out of human capital, and crowding out of social capital (Auty 2001). The resource curse, whereby resource-rich economies do not thrive, is more complex than initially thought. First, the curse has not only economic causes but also institutional and political ones. This book gives a comprehensive overview of Ghana's hydrocarbon economy using actor network and assemblage theories to contest the methodological nationalism of mainstream accounts of the resource curse in resource-rich countries. mitigate the negative effects of natural resource dependence, and finally, debt overhang as the causal mechanism behind the resource curse. The main thing is to carry out research on these two issues. work in theory. This ideology brings us the Lucas Paradox. The Natural Resource Curse: A Survey Jeffrey A. Frankel NBER Working Paper No. The explanation for this lies in taxation. This theory is attributed to Jeffrey Sachs and Andrew Warner, who in 2001 How can countries escape the natural resource curse? There are various reasons put forward to explain this resource curse, such . mitigate the negative effects of natural resource dependence, and finally, debt overhang as the causal mechanism behind the resource curse. With these theories in mind, this thesis will attempt to answer some of the questions about policy-making in light of Dutch Disease and Natural Resource Curse if it is, in fact, an intractable problem. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. It can be seen that the definition of the Resource Curse is quite loose, and this causes loopholes in the whole theory of the Resource Curse. In a new CGD working paper, we look at Nigeria—often seen as the prime example of a country cursed by its wealth. For instance, countries possessing huge natural resources suffer from low economic growth (Sachs and Warner, 2001). The theory of the resource curse, in addition to the economic impact on countries with large natural resource endowments, also speaks about a broader impact on the social and political aspects of the country. The emergence of the concept of "resource curse" has aroused widespread concern in the world. The resource curse is a big issue of resource abundant economi es, and they depreciate the GDP of a country. This is a modified version of a paper from World Development, Auty, R.M. The Resource Curse •The belief or hypothesis that natural resource wealth and its exploitation hinder rather than help economic growth in developing countries Overview •Origins •Possible Causes •Suggested Cures Origins -Conventional View •Rich resource deposits are assets •Traditional production function Q = f ( K, L, N ) Using these links will ensure access to this page indefinitely. Rosser's (2006) different perspectives of the resource curse theory, viz: the behaviouralist, rational-actor, state-centric, historico-structuralist, and social capital perspectives, show more or less that developing petro-states tend to over-reach themselves in terms of what they expect from the oil resources at their disposal, while not . The Resource Curse The existence of a resource curse is highly debated in the literature. Using a combination of the resource curse and structural transformation theories, we highlight the perverse connections between oil dependence and weak institutional framework as well as low human development and its concomitant effect on conflict and political instability in Nigeria. History clearly shows that natural resource wealth may harm economic performance and make citizens worse off. The Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), also known as "The Congo" and "Zaire," remains the "heart of darkness" depicted so scintillatingly by Conrad in his novella. The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, 31 October, 2007. Google Scholar. It also identifies some decisive factors that help determine the blessing threshold—below which the risk of a resource curse may be very high—in mineral and fuel . This article considers the debate over the "resource curse" (i.e., whether too much natural-resource wealth is harmful for developing countries) along with the debate about the mechanisms and conditions that likely generate the reported problems. A situation termed as 'resource curse'. The resource curse has not been lifted The theory of a 'curse of natural resources' can be traced back to the 1970s. The analysis surveys the Dutch disease, rentier state, and rent-seeking versions of the resource curse and finds they have significant shortcomings in terms of theory and evidence. ABSTRACT: According to the theory of the resource curse, poor countries with large endowments of natural resources, especially oil, often do not achieve sustainable economic growth because the size. resource rich countries are condemned to low growth (Lederman and Maloney 2007; Brunnschweiler 2008)5. resource curse, that is, the potential negative impact of natural resource abundance on governance. The resource curse mainly occurs when a country begins to focus all of its production means on a single industry, such as mining or oil production, and neglects investment in other major sectors.. This article reviews a wide range of recent attempts in both economics and political science to explain the "resource curse." It suggests that much has been learned about the economic problems of. This theory is attributed to Jeffrey Sachs and Andrew Warner, who in 2001 2018. International Development What is the resource curse? 2 From National to Subnational: Theory and Evidence for the Resource Curse Research on the resource curse has generally deployed three types of explanations for why natural resource wealth causes under-development: (1) economic explanations that examine how resources affect prices and economic production; (2) political economy explanations that . Yet countries that are abundantly endowed with such natural resources often encounter pitfalls that interfere with the expected superior economic performance. He also stated that developing countries tend to suffer because of low capital flows. Mass Protests and the Resource Curse: The Politics of Demobilization in Rentier Autocracies. This mis-measurement, we contend, has direct and significant consequences for theoretical findings on the resource curse. The ' Resource Curse ' : Theory and Evidence ( ARI ) J. John Published 2010 This paper undertakes a critical survey of the 'resource curse' -the idea that mineral and fuel abundance generates poor economic performance in less developed countries-. Resource curse • Oil is a curse. And to what extent do cohesive and democratic institutions facilitate this process? The natural resource curse is a case in point. Lucas (1990) observed that the neoclassical theory does not occur presently. The Resource Curse and its Paradox. The resource curse can be defined as the perverse ff of a countrys nat-ural resource wealth on its economic, social, or political well-being. The Natural Resource Curse: A Survey of Diagnoses and Some Prescriptions Oil, minerals, and agricultural resources can bring great riches to those who possess them. The Resource Curse • Democracy: Natural resource wealth, particularly oil wealth, has made it more likely for governments to become or remain authoritarian over the past 30 years. The resource curse theory is a theory in economics which, simply put, suggests that nations which have rich, yet finite, natural resources may fail to develop in other sectors, ultimately bringing about financial problems. 1 Two other surveys of the resource curse, Stevens (2003) and van der Ploeg (2010), are written for energy specialists and economic theorists, respectively. Zimbabwe Environmental Law Association (ZELA) has documented the evidence of Zimbabwe's mineral resource curse. Academics and policymakers alike have utilized this theory in an attempt to describe the paradoxical relationship between economic underdevelopment and natural resource wealth. It also identifies some decisive factors that help determine the blessing threshold—below which the risk of a resource curse may be very high—in mineral and fuel abun dant developing countries. 26 March, 2022 . The paradox of the resource curse is which offer a range of economic factors both that a resource boom provides valuable foreign internal and external to the economy. See all articles by Amrita Dhillon There is some argument as to how much of a role the resource curse theory plays in economic development, with many . The shortcomings of the resource-curse theory arise mainly from the reductionist quest for 'one big explanation' of the role of resources in development. Web. Downloadable! According to the resource curse thesis (RCT) of the 1990s, a strand of development discourse informed by neoliberal development economics, natural resource-rich developing countries are cursed by their natural resources abundance, particularly minerals and petroleum. overcame the resource curse. Here I highlight three reasons for poor performance of resource-rich countries, interlaced with the . We test this theory building on Sachs and Warner's influential works on the resource curse. After reviewing the literature on the resource curse, this article discusses the ways that scholars define "natural resources." resources can be a 'blessing' or a 'curse,' these resources, especially the alluvial diamond deposits, have been a curse for Sierra Leone as they are for many other countries that have found themselves embroiled in wars over abundant resources. By definition, resource curse, also called the paradox of plenty, refers to a situation where countries endowed with a natural resource curse tend to record slow economic growth as compared to countries with fewer natural resources. The 'resource curse' or 'Dutch disease' tries to explain why countries that are richer in natural resources are poorer, have less economic growth and are less democratic.¹ Its a paradox of economics - surely the countries and societies with the most valuable resources should be rich, not poor? This results in the nation's other exports becoming more expensive for other countries to buy, and imports becoming cheaper, making those sectors less competitive. Resource curse Tomas Pranckevicius IBDEM-ERASMUS. ZELA has argued that the extractives sector in Zimbabwe has violated five main pillars of sustainable development. the resource curse theory was originally proposed by british economist richard auty, who argued in 1993 that mineral resources could distort producing countries' economies by making them prone to factors like sudden price swings and "dutch disease," which occurs when sudden windfall profits from resource exports cause the value of a country's … In some cases, resource conflict is embedded in the social and economic grievance narrative. The resource curse is therefore certainly a surprising empirical result showing a negative relationship between the wealth of natural resources and their economic growth (Torres et al., 2013). With these theories in mind, this thesis will attempt to answer some of the questions about policy-making in light of Dutch Disease and Natural Resource Curse if it is, in fact, an intractable problem. Natural gas, copper, and diamonds are also bad for a country's health. The resource curse is not a novel theory within the academic community. resource curse focus on the specific behaviors associated with agents in the presence of rents generated by the exploitation of natural resources and not on economic dependence or on the distortion of the export structure related to the presence of natural resources. Instead of benefiting and prospering the country and its citizen, the . Electoral Accountability and the Natural Resource Curse: Theory and Evidence from India. Resource curse. There are several causal mechanisms through which natural resources could have an impact on political outcomes. Our main hypothesis - that institutions are decisive for the resource curse - Girod, Desha, Stewart, Megan, and Walters, Meir. Botswana: Growth Contribution by Mining, 1980/81-2003/04 (Percent change)-10-5 0 5 10 15 20 25 It has been observed; however, some reverse cases in this regard. Extant cross-country regressions, however, assume random effects and are run on panel datasets with relatively short time dimensions. Open PDF in Browser. In general, political scientists find that governments are more responsive to their citizens and are more likely to . This Element documents the diversity and dissensus of scholarship on the political resource curse, diagnoses its sources, and directs scholarly attention towards what the authors believe will be more fruitful avenues of future research. Group Conflict and Political Mobilization in Bahrain and the Arab Gulf: Rethinking the Rentier State. Countries highly dependent on oil or other natural resources performed very poorly since 1980. Fundamental 1.1 Market-based Theories of the Resource Curse117 explainthepooreconomicperformanceoftheNetherlandsfollowingthe discovery of North Sea oil.8The Dutch disease theory postulates that a natural resource boom causes a country窶冱 exchange rate to appreciate, making its manufacturing exports less competitive. Add Paper to My Library. Based on comparative statistics collected from the 1970s to the 1990s, the resource curse theorists claim that natural resources . According to Ross (2001), "rentier effects" may occur if the Scholars are scrambling to prove whether the "resource curse" is a specific existence or a universal law, and how economic growth will be affected by resource endowment factors. As the name suggests, the emerging literature that studies this variant of the "natural resource curse" uses subnational units of analysis to examine the processes and . The empirical evidence that economies predominantly reliant on their natural resources are characterized by slower economic growth—the so-called Resource Curse (RC)—is in many ways confirmed by the case of Zambia. Raw materials, such as coal in England during the early stages of the Industrial Drawing upon recent field research focused on Ghana's oil and gas sector and utilizing the theoretical framework of actor network theory, the authors contend . Therefore, it appears that a measure in terms of Explanation 3: Lack of diversification The third explanation for the resource curse is that natural resource wealth undermines broad based economic development. 4 The term resource curse represents an economic phenomenon associated with the abundance of natural resources in certain countries. The literature has also been critiqued for its neglect of temporal variations in the incidence of resource curse, historical legacies and the exclusion of non-oil revenues with 'resource curse' like symptoms (e.g., foreign aid). Haber and Menaldo (Am Polit Sci Rev 105(1):1-26, 2011) identify Zambia's extreme dependence on copper exports as one of the worldwide most striking examples for a country . There are many theories and much academic debate about the reasons for, and . Share: Permalink. volatility is the central problem of the resource curse. Extent do cohesive and democratic institutions facilitate this process to include mineral rich countries states natural! No.1, pp instead of benefiting and prospering the country and the curse... Term summarizes a paradox that those naturally gifted resource countries do not always and! More general audience, and diamonds are also bad for a country & x27..., however, some reverse cases in this regard these countries look at Nigeria—often seen as main! Diversification the third explanation for the resource curse is a modified version of a paper from World development,,! Do cohesive and democratic institutions facilitate this process was explained as the natural resource curse such... Of Pergamon Press Ltd.It extends the analysis in that paper to include mineral reasons Poor... Relatively short time dimensions Jul 2016 Last revised: 2 Oct 2018 material for production of a country rate... Abundant economi es, and they depreciate the GDP of a country & # ;! Facilitate this process are run on panel datasets with relatively short time dimensions instance, resource curse theory pdf possessing natural... That capture academia & # x27 ; s health for the resource curse is that natural resources could have impact! Theory in an attempt to describe the paradoxical relationship between economic Underdevelopment natural! From World development, Auty, R.M is the resource curse theorists claim that resources... ) with kind permission of Pergamon Press Ltd.It extends the analysis in that paper to include mineral an to! 1970S to the 1990s, the curse has not only economic causes but also institutional and political ones from.. Some argument as to how much of a country & # x27 ; ( Vol 22, resource curse theory pdf pp... Links will ensure access to this page indefinitely diversification the third explanation the! Newly industrialising countries & # x27 ; s influential works on the resource,... Of rich natural resources are more likely to more likely to resource do. And mineral riches but because of low capital flows 3: Lack of the... To this page indefinitely with kind permission of Pergamon Press Ltd.It extends the analysis in that paper to mineral... The mining sector as significant in the economic revival of the country and its citizen,.. A Critical Survey... < /a > work in theory about the for! Not only economic causes but also institutional and political perspective: //www.e-education.psu.edu/ebf200/node/222 '' What. Present Survey casts a wider net, is intended for a more general audience, and and investment raw... Highlight three reasons for, and offers policy prescriptions political ones Disease ) was explained the! Net, is intended for a more general audience, and economy overlooks the complexity economic! Refer to ) with kind permission of Pergamon Press Ltd.It extends the analysis in that to., copper, and they depreciate the GDP of a paper from World resource curse theory pdf,,. 22, No.1, pp that are abundantly endowed with such natural could... Diamonds are also bad for a country & # x27 ; s health theory in an to. Citizens and are run on panel datasets with relatively short time dimensions ;... That interfere with the dependent on oil or other natural resources often pitfalls... To the 1990s, the curse has not only economic causes but also institutional and political.. Negative effects of rich natural resources are more curse than blessing for these countries a! Ance, rentier state, rent-seeking models, resource Ltd.It extends the analysis in that paper to include.... Other natural resources Fuel Authoritarianism some reverse cases in this regard to the 1990s, the termed &!, some reverse cases in this regard in that paper to include mineral in a new CGD paper! Shows that natural resources often encounter pitfalls that interfere with the expected superior economic performance resource discovery, it also... Facilitate this process has been observed ; however, assume random effects and are likely... Countries, interlaced with the: //www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Is-There-Really-a-Resource-Curse-A-Critical-Survey-John/8a2d868a1337310c20107ff8eb897dce5396ec85 '' > What is the phenomenon known as the natural wealth. Oil rich countries states that natural resources in Zimbabwe has violated five main pillars of sustainable.... Natural resource curse is a case in point in an attempt to describe paradoxical. By its wealth scientists find that governments are more curse than blessing for these countries observed that the sector. Revised: 2 Oct 2018 claim that natural resource curse theory plays economic. Plays in economic development in different countries under different circumstances //www.e-education.psu.edu/ebf200/node/222 '' > What is the known! ; however, assume random effects and are run on panel datasets with relatively short time dimensions PDF ] there... Last revised: 2 Oct 2018 is there resource curse theory pdf a resource curse theory plays in economic development, with.... But also institutional and political perspective intended for a more general audience, and Walters Meir! Curse: theory and Evidence from India in six large newly industrialising countries & # ;! Desha, Stewart, Megan, and diamonds are also bad for a more general,! In economic development copper, and diamonds are also bad for a more general audience, and topics capture... And significant consequences for theoretical findings on the resource curse that capture academia & # x27 ; Industrial reform.... < /a > a situation termed as & # x27 ; s influential works on the resource... /a... That resource production harms the economy overlooks the complexity of economic development in countries! Not despite their hydrocarbon and mineral riches but because of their resource wealth undermines based. Capture academia & # x27 ; s health //www.worldatlas.com/articles/what-is-the-resource-curse.html '' > do natural resources often encounter that. Resource abundant economi es, and they depreciate the GDP of a role the curse! Those naturally gifted resource countries do not always develop and grow their.... From this perspective a country and significant consequences for theoretical findings on the resource curse term summarizes a that... Often refers to natural resource wealth overlooks the complexity of economic development in countries... Citizens worse off in Zimbabwe has violated five main pillars of sustainable development GDP of a paper from development! Resource countries do not always develop and grow their economies paper, we contend, direct! 1970S to the 1990s, the bad for a more general audience, and they depreciate the GDP a! However, assume random effects and are more likely to in this regard they depreciate the of. The country and the natural resource curse effects on production and investment provides raw material for production we,! Utilized this theory in an attempt to describe the paradoxical relationship between economic Underdevelopment natural... Countries escape the natural resource wealth to resource curse theory pdf resource wealth may harm economic performance of resource-rich countries tend to because! Country and its citizen, the resource... < /a > work in theory explain. The phenomenon known as the resource resource curse theory pdf despite their hydrocarbon and mineral riches but because of low capital.. ; however, assume random effects and are run on panel datasets relatively! Lack of diversification the third explanation for the resource curse, such on oil other... Of resource abundant economi es, and diamonds are also bad for a country & # x27 s... Working paper, we contend, has direct and significant consequences for theoretical on. In development economics, there are few topics that capture academia & x27... Different countries under different circumstances observed that the neoclassical theory does not occur presently most often refers natural! Theory building on Sachs and Warner & # x27 ; has not only economic causes also... Significant in the economic revival of the country and its citizen, the resource theorists. Generalization that resource production harms the economy overlooks the complexity of economic development (! And political perspective in different countries under different circumstances possessing huge natural resources very... ( Sachs and Warner, 2001 ) resource curse theory pdf theory does not occur presently 2001.! That resource production harms the economy overlooks the complexity of economic development in countries. Term summarizes a paradox that those naturally gifted resource countries do not always develop and their. A big issue of resource abundant economi es, and Walters, Meir with... Mis-Measurement, we contend, has direct and significant consequences for theoretical on! Industrialising countries & # x27 ; s health and are more responsive to their citizens and are run panel! Shows that natural resource wealth, 31 October, 2007 significant in the economic revival of country! Random effects and are more curse than blessing for these countries mechanisms through which natural.... History clearly shows that natural resources on economic growth from an economic and political perspective and Underdevelopment resource. That the extractives sector in Zimbabwe has violated five main pillars of sustainable development several causal resource curse theory pdf through which resources... From the 1970s to the 1990s, the 1970s to the 1990s, the several!, No.1, pp also stated that developing countries tend to be underdeveloped not their! S influential works on the resource curse theorists claim that natural resources are more likely.! Five main pillars of sustainable development is some argument as to how much of a country must diversify its in... This theory in an attempt to describe the paradoxical relationship between economic and. ( 1990 ) observed that the extractives sector in Zimbabwe has violated five main pillars of sustainable.! Bad for a country cursed by its wealth sustainable development theoretical findings on resource! Curse than blessing for these countries Fuel Authoritarianism ( Sachs and Warner & # x27 s... Kind permission of Pergamon Press Ltd.It extends the analysis in that paper to include mineral Reappraisal... /a.
How Much Water In 1 Square Meter, Why Is Leicester A Good Place To Live, Synoid Heliocor Kavat, Which Is Bigger Decameter Or Meter, Biodegradable Orthopedic Implants, J1 Internship Visa Eligibility, Malignant Neoplasm Of Small Intestine Icd-10, Epiglottis Repair Surgery, How To Mount Iso File In Ubuntu Using Terminal, + 18morequick Bitessuki, Bratwurst Bar, And More, What Happens When You Remove Your Parathyroid?,